News

New Build vs Older Rental: What Net Yield Really Looks Like in NZ

  • DSC03828 2 (1)
  • Gross yield is rent divided by purchase price before any costs come out, so it isn’t what lands in your account. In an illustrative Christchurch comparison, two $720,000 rentals with the same rent and the same advertised 4.3% gross yield came out at roughly 2.0% net for the older property and roughly 2.6% net for the new build. 

    This is general information, not financial or investment advice. Figures are illustrative and will vary by property, location, financing and management. 

    Why the advertised yield isn’t the real return 

    Advertised yield is almost always gross, before a single cost comes out. Two properties with a similar advertised yield can produce very different net returns once management, maintenance, insurance, rates, vacancy and compliance costs are counted. Tax isn’t the difference: mortgage interest deductibility is back to 100% and the bright-line test is a uniform 2 years, whether a property is new or existing. 

    Where the gap comes from

    In the comparison, both rentals earn about $600 a week ($31,200 a year) and share the same management, vacancy, rates and insurance costs. The difference is maintenance: 1% of value a year for the older rental ($7,200) versus 0.4% for the new build ($2,880). That leaves net rent of $14,330 against $18,650, before any mortgage costs or tax. 

    If the older property isn’t already Healthy Homes compliant, bringing it up to standard can add a further $1,000 to $20,000 one-off. A new build is compliant from day one. 

    Why the gap tends to widen 

    Over ten years, maintenance on the older rental comes to at least $72,000 on this property, before one-off items like a re-roof or rewire become likely. The new build comes to around $28,800 at 0.4%, with structural defects separately covered by a 10-year structural warranty. 

    It’s rarely the everyday numbers that hurt a return, it’s a single unbudgeted bill landing in the same year the cashflow was already geared tightly around the advertised figure. None of this means avoiding older rentals, plenty perform very well. It’s about knowing where the real costs sit, and budgeting for them, before you run the numbers on a specific property. 

    Get the full cashflow comparison 

    Want the line-by-line numbers, the ten-year cost comparison and an illustrative five-year scenario? Download our guide, New Build vs Old: An Investor’s Real Cashflow Comparison. 

    Download the full guide here
    Form CTA